I've always been a fan of the Community Colleges. I taught Accounting at Paradise Valley Community College and I've taken advantage of the outstanding Spanish and Math programs at Phoenix College.
But the Community Colleges have some serious problems. You might think that this is one of the problems, but this is actually small potatoes.
The district came under intense scrutiny when it was revealed in the fall that Mesa Community College leaders had led all-expenses-paid trips to other countries over five years costing more than $324,000. A ban on administrative foreign travel remains in place until June.
Two college presidents lost their jobs earlier this month after seeking payment for foreign trips that often included generous amounts of sightseeing and side trips.
These are great stories and the Republic and Tribune should be commended for their work uncovering these junkets. But, I'd let the Community College Presidents fly to China every week if they would stop ripping off the state in other areas.
Take dual enrollment. Some kids to really well in high school, so the Community Colleges and high schools offer courses that count for college credit. That sounds fine. But both schools charge the state for the full cost of the student. That's right. The Community College and the high school each seek full reimbursement from the state, and the state reimburses the schools as if there were two students.
The Arizona Tax Research Association has been on top of the scam from the beginning. Here's ATRA's newsletter from January 2001.
Napolitano's office is wise to the trick. Here's a Republic article from 2004.
Last year, dual enrollment was one of the programs Gov. Janet Napolitano suggested eliminating in the early rounds of budget talks. Despite an estimated savings for the state of $4 million, the program survived.
Four million dollars a year. Wow. But what's worse than the financial double dip is the fact that the classes leave kids ill prepared for real college courses. Here's what one Community College faculty member wrote in 2001.
But, as a full-time faculty member in the Maricopa Community College District, I know that quality is frequently lacking in dual enrollment courses. All too often, the students are academically underprepared for college level mastery or lack the facilities and scheduling to do true college work.
Dual enrollment courses may rip off the taxpayer and leave the students unprepared, but at least they are, like you know, real courses...English and math and stuff.
The Community Colleges have another great scam going as well. They create a bunch of recreational courses and get the state to pay for them. Here are some examples of where your tax dollars are going.
•Stress Management (Maricopa; 2 credits)
•Sculpture for Personal Development (Pima; 2 credits)
•Men in Transition (Maricopa; 2 credits)
•Rich Dad Poor Dad: Secrets to Personal Financial Wealth (Pima; 2 credits)
•Quilting – eight sections (EAC; 2 credits)
•Flower Essences (Maricopa; 1 credit)
•Mystery Dinner Theater (CAC; 0.5 credit)
•Aromatherapy (Maricopa; 1 credit)
•Phoenix Zoo Lights (CAC; 0.5 credit)
•Raft the Grand Canyon (CAC; 2 credits)
•Personal Spiritual Development (Maricopa; 2 credits)
•Developing Self Esteem (Pima; 2 credits)
Men in Transition? I should take that. I've been in a mid-life crisis since high school.
These courses seem harmless, after all, they only chew up a few million dollars of the state's education budget each year. But these course offerings act as a distraction. Students often use the Community College as a springboard to the Universities. Community College students who have taken two years of class work often discover that they only have a few classes that will transfer to a four-year program. Sure, they are experts in Flower Essences, Quilting and Sculpture, but that doesn't get you into ASU's Business Program.
Give me Community College Presidents who are willing to stop double charging the state for dual enrollment classes and will stop forcing taxpayers to pay for Quilting and Aromatherapy classes and I would be happy to send them to Europe every couple weeks. The students would be better off and the state would save money.
Absent that, maybe the Republicans in the Legislature would be willing to support Governor Napolitano's 2004 suggestion that this silly stuff be eliminated.
Recent Comments